What?!? I don't know how you can say Kearse was as reliable as Baldwin?!?
Baldwin literally led the NFL in catch rate through most of season and tied for most TDs!
I think he ended up finishing 3rd in catch rate but here is an article from the end of October when he was still leading:
Seahawks’ Doug Baldwin leads NFL with 84 consecutive catches without a drop | The Seattle Times
The thing with Kearse, he is on a run first team with a mobile QB and Jimmy Graham - he is literally the 5th option at best.
The 5th option might as well be a rookie deal type player, otherwise it's just a waste of money. Put Kevin Smith or Kasen Williams as your 5th option and MAYBE the offense goes from being (and I am just picking random numbers here to illustrate the point) 80/100 to 78/100.