I actually watched all the games, i dont think hes horrible and im not on anyones nuts, with what qb's we had he was the best choice, simpletarry didnt like nate so therefore wasnt even going to give him a chance, carr really sucks ass hard so he shouldnt have even been allowed to take a snap, and while blacksmith was dope, he just didnt know enough of the playbook and had the same problem of being limited by simpletarrys play calling, i dont think smith is the answer but hes a deccent back-up imo