Sink or swim time for 2008 draft class
http://www.sacbee.com/static/weblogs/49ers/archives/2010/05/sink-or-swim-ti.html
The NFL rule of thumb is that one should wait three years before making an assessment about a draft class. If that's the case, judgment day will occur this season for the 49ers' class of 2008, which was controversial from the first day. Of all Scot McCloughan's drafts, 2008 was the smallest in numbers - only six players taken - and also had the lowest first-round pick, Kentwan Balmer, who was taken 29th overall. Heading into 2010, all of the players still have question marks next to their names, but many also will have an opportunity to establish themselves for the first time in Year Three.
Kentwan Balmer, DL, 1st round, 29th overall.
Balmer was a controversial pick from the outset because he wasn't DeSean Jackson, the Cal receiver many Bay Area fans were hoping the 49ers would select. (In fact, the 49ers skipped Jackson twice). Instead the 49ers saw Balmer as a prototypical 3-4 defensive end - he stands 6-5 - and as someone who has the base (read: big butt and thighs) to move to nose tackle. But while Balmer has shown a flash or two at left defensive end, he hasn't been nearly consistent enough to be considered for a starting spot. Defensive linemen rarely make an impact right away in the NFL, and that fact affords Balmer a bit of a grace period. However, it's difficult to see him getting off to a fast start in 2010 given that offseason shoulder surgery will keep him out of spring practices.
Chilo Rachal, G, 2nd round, 39th overall
"Chilo's gonna make me knock him out." That's what Mike Singletary said (video here) after Rams' defensive lineman C.J. Ah You - who is nearly 50 pounds lighter than Rachal - bull-rushed the 49ers guard and sacked quarterback Shaun Hill on Oct. 4 last season. Singletary considered benching Rachal - in hindsight, maybe the threat was motivation - but ultimately gave him the chance to redeem himself. Rachal responded by playing better during the second half of the season, and that's a good reason why Rachal has a solid chance to be the team's breakout star in 2010. The 49ers need him to play like a veteran. "I just have to use what I did at the end of last season to continue to get better and not have the same season this year," Rachal recently told 49ers.com. "I want to make last year my worst season." Rachal will likely be starting next to a rookie, Anthony Davis, who, like both Balmer and Rachal in 2008, enters the league after his junior season of college. After drafting two offensive linemen in the first round this year, the 49ers will have more options along the offensive line. If Rachal struggles, David Baas could move from left to right guard.
Reggie Smith, S, 3rd round, 75th overall.
When the 49ers drafted Smith, they wanted him to play cornerback, the position he played as a senior at Oklahoma. Mike Nolan wasn't comfortable with his depth at cornerback at the time, and the plan was to make Smith into a press cornerback, someone who would play opposite Nate Clements. Smith, however, struggled at cornerback during the preseason of 2008. After the season, the 49ers decided to move him to safety, which meant that he had a second "rookie" campaign in 2009. He had a much more promising offseason last year and always seemed to be around the ball in the preseason. This year the 49ers are counting on him to have a more important role at safety. It doesn't look as if the 49ers will re-sign free-agent Mark Roman, a dependable veteran in recent seasons, meaning they are counting on Smith in case something happens to starter Dashon Goldson.
Cody Wallace, C, 4th round, 107th overall.
Nolan and McCloughan liked Wallace because of his hard-scrabble background and because he showed true grit when matched against superior players at the 2008 Senior Bowl. But Wallace's fight hasn't been enough to compensate for his lack of size, and he was rag-dolled routinely in practice as a rookie. Wallace improved last season, spent some practice time at guard and played in exactly one game. The 49ers' offensive line is as talented as it's been in 10 years. It will be very interesting to see if guys like David Baas and Tony Wragge take snaps at center this offseason. If they do, it might be bad news for Wallace. The good news for Wallace: The 49ers did not draft a center, something that would have spelled certain doom.
Josh Morgan, WR, 6th round, 174th overall.
Who would have thought the jewel of the 2008 draft class would have come in the sixth round? The 49ers benefitted from the fact that Morgan played in a run-first system at Virginia Tech that featured A.) a mediocre quarterback and B.) a stud receiver in Eddie Royal. Morgan was overlooked and didn't even take part in the 2008 Senior Bowl. Morgan is the strongest wideout on the team, and he has perhaps the best hops of any 49er. (He had a vertical leap of 40 ½ inches at his pro day). The 49ers love Morgan because he is an excellent downfield blocker and because he's deceptively fast (4.46 40). But like every other member of his draft class, he hasn't always been consistent. (See video above).
Larry Grant, LB, 7th round, 214th overall.
Seventh-round picks often fail to make the final roster, and that was the case with Grant, an Ohio State product. But Grant's brief tenure also highlights how demanding the 49ers are on their inside linebackers. Singletary wants someone with a very specific set of skills. Grant was plucked from the 49ers' practice squad by St. Louis, where Grant has spent the last two seasons.