No, we just don't think he was the only one juicing, therefore it does and should count.
That's like you selling weed and it's the best around, then you get popped for adding chemicals to your shit, everyone's doing it, but since yours is the dankest shit... everyone says it's tainted and shouldn't be considered the best.
an OG grower had the best shit until you came around, his didn't have a reputation as having chemicals although he might've used them... because you got popped though, some people consider this guy to still be the best ever.